Most Underrated Colleges by ROI

These are the schools that pay off without the famous name. Each scores 70+ on our ROI scale but has fewer than 10,000 students and admits more than 25% of applicants. You get the outcomes without paying for the brand - exactly what the prestige rankings tend to miss.

50 schools ranked

Data: 2024-25 College Scorecard release

#	School	ROI	Net Price	10yr Earnings	Median Debt	Completion	Tier
1	Colorado School of Mines Golden, CO	94	$28,690	$97,335	$23,000	81.7%	Exceptional
2	Bentley University Waltham, MA	94	$37,930	$120,959	$25,023	86.8%	Exceptional
3	Albany College of Pharmacy and Health Sciences Albany, NY	94	$29,882	$131,426	$25,500	67.5%	Exceptional
4	Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute Troy, NY	93	$36,228	$102,051	$23,750	83.6%	Exceptional
5	United States Merchant Marine Academy Kings Point, NY	93	$6,174	$90,610	$8,833	82.4%	Exceptional
6	Lehigh University Bethlehem, PA	93	$36,931	$105,584	$21,960	87.9%	Exceptional
7	Illinois Institute of Technology Chicago, IL	92	$18,425	$82,592	$25,000	75.2%	Exceptional
8	Massachusetts Maritime Academy Buzzards Bay, MA	92	$21,582	$82,392	$25,000	74.1%	Exceptional
9	New Jersey Institute of Technology Newark, NJ	92	$16,504	$84,276	$21,000	72.8%	Exceptional
10	Stevens Institute of Technology Hoboken, NJ	92	$41,346	$108,772	$27,000	86.9%	Exceptional
11	Lafayette College Easton, PA	92	$34,433	$91,410	$16,000	87.6%	Exceptional
12	SUNY Maritime College Throggs Neck, NY	91	$22,367	$95,951	$23,250	64.4%	Exceptional
13	William & Mary Williamsburg, VA	91	$19,096	$73,490	$18,500	89.4%	Exceptional
14	University of Washington-Bothell Campus Bothell, WA	91	$12,319	$78,466	$14,615	65.3%	Exceptional
15	University of Washington-Tacoma Campus Tacoma, WA	91	$10,163	$78,466	$14,615	63.2%	Exceptional
16	University of Florida-Online Gainesville, FL	91	$4,815	$71,588	$15,000	84.7%	Exceptional
17	California State University Maritime Academy Vallejo, CA	90	$20,555	$94,784	$24,965	59.7%	Exceptional
18	Santa Clara University Santa Clara, CA	90	$50,062	$109,183	$19,162	87.9%	Exceptional
19	MCPHS University Boston, MA	90	$39,545	$125,557	$25,000	62.0%	Exceptional
20	Worcester Polytechnic Institute Worcester, MA	90	$43,071	$103,470	$27,000	89.7%	Exceptional
21	Missouri University of Science and Technology Rolla, MO	90	$16,298	$82,957	$23,250	64.4%	Exceptional
22	Rose-Hulman Institute of Technology Terre Haute, IN	89	$42,513	$101,253	$25,000	78.2%	Strong
23	Michigan Technological University Houghton, MI	89	$14,182	$78,198	$24,990	68.1%	Strong
24	New Mexico Institute of Mining and Technology Socorro, NM	89	$9,873	$76,489	$19,085	57.0%	Strong
25	University of Portland Portland, OR	89	$28,210	$82,804	$21,370	79.8%	Strong
26	Villanova University Villanova, PA	89	$43,756	$100,423	$25,874	91.9%	Strong
27	Milwaukee School of Engineering Milwaukee, WI	89	$22,453	$89,070	$27,000	67.1%	Strong
28	Neumont College of Computer Science Salt Lake City, UT	89	$35,205	$97,827	N/A	62.7%	Strong
29	University of San Diego San Diego, CA	88	$30,365	$86,522	$22,940	83.7%	Strong
30	Kettering University Flint, MI	88	$34,660	$94,823	$27,000	70.8%	Strong
31	University of Health Sciences and Pharmacy in St. Louis Saint Louis, MO	88	$31,817	$137,047	$17,755	61.7%	Strong
32	Clarkson University Potsdam, NY	88	$30,305	$89,696	$26,000	74.9%	Strong
33	Ohio Northern University Ada, OH	88	$24,478	$80,928	$27,000	75.5%	Strong
34	Virginia Military Institute Lexington, VA	88	$17,113	$77,369	$22,996	76.2%	Strong
35	Chamberlain University-Michigan Troy, MI	88	$28,045	$92,405	$20,919	100.0%	Strong
36	Trinity College Hartford, CT	87	$34,832	$90,779	$23,000	83.8%	Strong
37	Mount Carmel College of Nursing Columbus, OH	87	$10,420	$75,103	$22,082	53.8%	Strong
38	Bucknell University Lewisburg, PA	87	$40,766	$93,807	$27,000	86.3%	Strong
39	University of Connecticut-Avery Point Groton, CT	87	$13,807	$73,997	$21,500	61.6%	Strong
40	University of Connecticut-Hartford Campus Hartford, CT	87	$16,403	$73,997	$21,500	65.0%	Strong
41	Chamberlain University-Missouri St. Louis, MO	87	$30,716	$92,405	$20,919	100.0%	Strong
42	Saint Joseph's University - Philadelphia Philadelphia, PA	86	$29,689	$86,881	$25,500	78.8%	Strong
43	Thomas Jefferson University Philadelphia, PA	86	$28,928	$77,449	$14,744	68.6%	Strong
44	Chamberlain University-Virginia Vienna, VA	86	$33,199	$92,405	$20,919	100.0%	Strong
45	University of the Pacific Stockton, CA	85	$25,447	$78,445	$19,500	69.0%	Strong
46	University of Rochester Rochester, NY	85	$29,278	$79,042	$21,000	85.4%	Strong
47	Union College Schenectady, NY	85	$34,561	$88,604	$25,337	80.4%	Strong
48	Case Western Reserve University Cleveland, OH	85	$41,190	$87,989	$24,000	87.2%	Strong
49	Trinity University San Antonio, TX	85	$23,464	$71,668	$22,954	84.0%	Strong
50	University of Connecticut-Waterbury Campus Waterbury, CT	85	$10,875	$73,997	$21,500	52.7%	Strong

All Rankings Browse All Schools Compare Schools ROI Calculator

Other Rankings

Best ROI Overall Best Public Schools Best Private Schools Best Large Schools Fastest Payback Lowest Debt Worst ROI

How We Rank

Rankings are based on our ROI score (0-100), which weights five quantifiable factors: Earnings Premium (30%), Payback Period (25%), Debt-to-Earnings (20%), Completion Rate (15%), and Loan Repayment (10%). All data comes from the U.S. Department of Education College Scorecard. No subjective criteria are used.

Full methodology →

Common Questions

What is the best underrated college by ROI?

Colorado School of Mines tops this list at 94/100 on our ROI scale, the highest among the 50 schools ranked here. Rankings weigh net price against median graduate earnings from U.S. Department of Education College Scorecard data - no prestige guesswork.

Which school on this list has the highest graduate earnings?

University of Health Sciences and Pharmacy in St. Louis reports the highest median earnings here, about $137,047 ten years after enrollment. In our view higher earnings alone don't make the best value, since what you pay matters just as much - which is why the ranking weighs cost too.

What is the most affordable school on this list?

University of Florida-Online carries the lowest net price among the ranked schools, about $4,815 a year after grants and scholarships. Net price is what students actually pay, not the published sticker price.

How are these schools ranked?

We score every school 0 to 100 on five quantifiable factors: earnings premium (30%), payback period (25%), debt-to-earnings (20%), completion rate (15%), and loan repayment (10%). All figures come from the U.S. Department of Education College Scorecard, with no subjective reputation scoring. Of the 50 schools here, 50 earn an ROI score of 60 or higher.