2026 College Value Report
We scored 1,666 four-year U.S. colleges on financial return on investment using federal College Scorecard data. 43% scored Below Benchmark. Only 18% scored Strong or better. The gap between the highest- and lowest-earning majors is $69,834 a year. Here is what the data shows.
The Numbers That Matter
Score Distribution: Most Schools Don't Score Well
The ROI score scale runs 0-100. We group schools into five tiers. The distribution is heavily skewed toward the bottom: 709 of 1,666 schools (43%) fall into the Below Benchmark tier, scoring below 45. Only 82 schools (5%) reach Exceptional. The median school scores 50.
Top Schools by ROI
The top schools share a pattern: high earnings, moderate net prices (10 of 11 under $30,000/year after aid), and strong completion rates. 2 public universities make the list (University of California-Berkeley and Georgia Institute of Technology-Main Campus), competing on equal terms with schools that cost twice as much at sticker price. Schools with the same score share a rank, so every school tied at 97, the score that closes the top 10, is listed.
| # | School | Score | Net Price/yr | 10yr Earnings | Type |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| T1 | Massachusetts Institute of Technology | 99 | $20,111 | $143,372 | Private Nonprofit |
| T1 | Stanford University | 99 | $13,807 | $124,080 | Private Nonprofit |
| T3 | University of Chicago | 98 | $14,860 | $91,885 | Private Nonprofit |
| T3 | Rice University | 98 | $13,370 | $89,718 | Private Nonprofit |
| T5 | University of California-Berkeley | 97 | $13,481 | $92,446 | Public |
| T5 | Yale University | 97 | $23,777 | $100,533 | Private Nonprofit |
| T5 | Georgia Institute of Technology-Main Campus | 97 | $12,116 | $102,772 | Public |
| T5 | University of Notre Dame | 97 | $26,780 | $99,980 | Private Nonprofit |
| T5 | Carnegie Mellon University | 97 | $31,944 | $114,862 | Private Nonprofit |
| T5 | University of Pennsylvania | 97 | $28,699 | $111,371 | Private Nonprofit |
| T5 | Vanderbilt University | 97 | $15,846 | $91,565 | Private Nonprofit |
The $70,000 Major Gap
What you study matters more than where you go. The highest-earning major in our database (Pharmacy, $92,722 average median earnings) pays $69,834 more per year than the lowest-earning major (Drama/Theatre Arts and Stagecraft, $22,888). Over a 30-year career, that compounds to roughly $2.1 million in cumulative earnings difference. Same four years, same diploma frame, completely different financial trajectory.
Highest-Earning Majors
Lowest-Earning Majors
Earnings are average median 10-year earnings across all schools reporting data for that major. Filtered to majors with 10+ reporting institutions. Browse all 304 majors →
Public vs. Private: The Value Gap
Public universities average 57 on our ROI score against 48 for private nonprofits, a gap of 9 points, while charging 40% less ($14,687/year vs $24,329/year average net price). For-profit schools average 32, with an average net price of $27,822/year and average 10-year earnings of $52,923.
The headline is clear: on average, you pay about $9,600 more per year at a private nonprofit and get essentially the same average 10-year earnings ($56,094 vs $55,220). For-profit schools charge the most and produce the least. The exceptions exist - some private schools like Rice ($13,370 net) and Stanford ($13,807 net) are cheaper than many publics after aid - but they are exceptions, not the rule.
Where You Go to College Matters: State-Level ROI
The median ROI score varies by 51 points between states and territories with 8 or more scored schools, depending on where you attend college. California and Connecticut (median: 71) lead the country. Geography is an underrated variable in the college ROI equation.
Highest-ROI States and Territories (Median Score)
Lowest-ROI States and Territories (Median Score)
Median ROI score among all four-year institutions in the state with College Scorecard data, for states with 8 or more scored schools. Count in parentheses. Read: How State Choice Changes Your ROI →
Seven Key Findings
The majority of U.S. colleges are a questionable financial investment
1,031 of 1,666 schools (62%) score below 60/100 - the threshold where the financial case starts to weaken. At 709 schools (43%), the ROI score is below 45. These are institutions where the typical graduate's earnings barely exceed - or fail to exceed - what they would have earned without a degree.
What you study matters more than where you go
The $69,834 gap between the highest-earning major (Pharmacy, $92,722) and the lowest (Drama/Theatre Arts and Stagecraft, $22,888) is the spread across majors with 10 or more reporting schools. An electrical engineering graduate from a state school will typically out-earn a liberal arts graduate from an expensive private university.
Public universities are the better financial bet for most students
At 9 ROI points higher on average (57 vs 48) and about $9,600 less per year, public schools deliver equivalent earnings at lower cost. The private schools that beat publics on ROI - MIT, Stanford, Rice, Chicago - do so because of exceptionally generous financial aid, not because private schools are inherently better.
For-profit schools are almost never worth it
Average score: 32/100. Average net price: $27,822/year - the highest of any category. Average earnings: $52,923 - the lowest. There are 88 for-profit four-year institutions in our dataset. The math works at almost none of them.
The debt-to-income picture is worse than the headline suggests
Median debt is $23,250 against median earnings of $53,607 - a ratio of 0.43, well within the safe zone. But 5.4% of schools have a debt-to-earnings ratio above 1.0, meaning median graduates there owe more than a year of earnings, and the 90th-percentile school sits at 0.87. The median hides the tail risk.
Geography is an underappreciated variable
The 51-point gap between the highest-median states (California and Connecticut, 71) and the lowest (Puerto Rico, 20) reflects real differences in state funding, institutional quality, and regional labor markets.
Net price is not the best predictor of ROI
Some of the best values are also the most expensive at sticker price: MIT ($20,111 net) and Stanford ($13,807 net) have top ROI scores because their generous aid and strong outcomes more than compensate. Some of the lowest-scoring schools have seemingly affordable net prices ($10,000-$15,000/yr) but produce graduates who earn less than the no-college baseline.
Methodology & Data
All data in this report comes from the U.S. Department of Education College Scorecard (2023-24 academic year). ROI scores are calculated using a five-component weighted algorithm: earnings premium (30%), payback period (25%), debt-to-earnings ratio (20%), completion rate (15%), and loan repayment success (10%). Scores are percentile-normalized across all 1,666 institutions with sufficient data. The $41,800 high school graduate earnings baseline (2022) is from the National Center for Education Statistics. Full methodology, formulas, and caveats are on our methodology page.
Earnings data reflects students who entered college roughly 10 years before the measurement date. All figures are in nominal dollars. Individual results vary based on major, effort, financial aid, and career decisions.
Explore the data
Every school in this report has a full profile with sub-scores, earnings by major, net price by income bracket, and peer comparisons.
Published April 4, 2026 by the CampusROI Editorial Team. Data from U.S. Department of Education College Scorecard and Bureau of Labor Statistics. For press inquiries, data requests, or corrections: editor@campusroi.com.