Uta Mesivta of Kiryas Joel

Uta Mesivta of Kiryas Joel is a Hasidic religious institution serving the Satmar community in Monroe, NY, and the conventional ROI framework applied to this school produces deeply unusual numbers that need careful context. The overall ROI score is 39 (Poor Value, red tier), but the institution is not operating as a labor-market credentialing engine. Tuition is $16,000 with a net price of just $4,156, and four-year total cost is roughly $16,624 - extraordinarily low for a private nonprofit. There is no median federal debt reported, which yields a perfect debt-to-earnings score of 100. However, the earnings story is severe: median earnings are $23,600 six years after enrollment and only $31,853 at ten years, both well below the wages a typical high-school graduate earns nationally. The earnings premium is actually negative (-0.189), meaning graduates earn less than non-college peers. The Scorecard payback period of 999 years is the algorithm's way of saying the cost is never recouped through wage premiums. Completion rate is reasonable at 70.2%. The honest assessment: this is a religious-studies school whose mission is theological formation within a closed community, and traditional ROI metrics simply do not capture its purpose.

This institution fits members of the Satmar Hasidic community pursuing religious study within their tradition. Pell rate is 87.4%, the highest end of the spectrum, and enrollment is 2,957. The financial-aid profile reflects very low household incomes among enrolled students. Career outcomes track community-internal roles (teaching, religious leadership, community service) rather than the wage-labor markets the Scorecard measures. Outside students should not consider this institution; community members should weigh it on theological and family criteria rather than on ROI metrics.