By Ryan Mercer · CampusROI Editorial Team
Best College Value in Pennsylvania: Top Schools by ROI (2026)
Pennsylvania has two Ivy-equivalent schools (CMU and Penn) with strong ROI at $28,000-$32,000 net, and Penn State as the flagship public value at $20,000-$25,000 net.
Pennsylvania's higher education market is unusual: two world-class private universities (Carnegie Mellon and Penn) that routinely beat public schools on ROI at their average net prices, plus a large state system anchored by Penn State.
Top Pennsylvania Schools by ROI Score
| Rank | School | ROI Score | Net Price | 10-Yr Earnings | Grad Rate |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Carnegie Mellon | 97/100 | $31,944 | $114,862 | 94% |
| 1 | U of Pennsylvania | 97/100 | $28,699 | $111,371 | 97% |
| 3 | Lehigh University | 93/100 | $36,931 | $105,584 | 88% |
| 4 | Lafayette College | 92/100 | $34,433 | $91,410 | 88% |
| 4 | Swarthmore College | 92/100 | $23,149 | $80,257 | 92% |
| 6 | Villanova University | 89/100 | $43,756 | $100,423 | 92% |
Carnegie Mellon: Tech School Value
CMU scores 97/100. At $31,944 average net price, it's cheaper than many non-elite private schools. Its CS and engineering programs are top-5 nationally; graduates routinely earn $130,000-$160,000 four years out.
CMU is the right answer for students who get in and receive meaningful aid. Its 18% acceptance rate means it's not for everyone - but its ROI case is overwhelming for those who do.
Penn: Wharton and the Ivy Network
Penn at $28,699 net, $111,371 earnings, 97% graduation rate. Wharton graduates average $120,000+ starting salaries in consulting and finance. Penn's engineering school is strong. Its medical pipeline is among the best in the country.
Penn's average net price of $28,699 masks a wide distribution - low-income students pay under $5,000, high-income students pay $70,000+. Verify your specific price before assuming Penn is affordable.
Swarthmore: Liberal Arts at Elite Outcomes
Swarthmore at $23,149 net, $80,257 earnings, 92% graduation rate. ROI 92/100. It's the strongest liberal arts value in Pennsylvania for students who want a small school. Engineering program is unusual for a liberal arts college and well-regarded.
Penn State: The Public Flagship
Penn State University Park is the in-state public option for students who can't get into (or can't afford) CMU or Penn. Net price $20,000-$25,000 for residents, strong engineering and agriculture programs, Smeal College of Business has solid outcomes.
The Penn State brand is strong in Pennsylvania's business community. For Pennsylvanians staying in-state, Penn State's network has real labor market value.
The Bottom Line
Pennsylvania's unusual for having two private schools (CMU and Penn) that beat its public flagship on ROI at their aid-adjusted prices. For high-achieving students who get meaningful aid from CMU or Penn, those schools are the right call. For everyone else, Penn State University Park is a solid public option. Swarthmore is the best liberal arts value.
Data: College Scorecard 2024.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which Pennsylvania university has the best ROI?
Carnegie Mellon (97/100, $31,944 net, $114,862 earnings) and Penn (97/100, $28,699 net, $111,371 earnings) tie at the top. For more accessible schools, Penn State University Park offers solid public flagship value at $20,000-$25,000 net.
Is Penn State worth it?
For Pennsylvania residents studying engineering, business, or agriculture, yes - Penn State has strong outcomes at $20,000-$25,000 net price. For non-residents paying $37,000+/year, the math requires a major-specific case.
Is Carnegie Mellon worth the cost?
CMU scores 97/100 ROI at $31,944 net price and $114,862 median earnings. CS and engineering graduates earn $130,000-$160,000 four years out. Yes - CMU is one of the best technology school values in the country for families who qualify for aid.
Run your own numbers
Every family's situation is different. Use our tools to model your specific scenario.